My Manifesto

Roberto Calas, fantasy author, father, fiance, artist, pilot, juggler, and ocassional hit-man, discusses writing, eBooks, fantasy, marketing and spiders.
Showing posts with label salet. Show all posts
Showing posts with label salet. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2009

Of Satyrs and Salets

Okay, something that bothers me fierce but could just be a touch of OCD. You're reading a story, a fantasy story, set in a medieval-England style make-believe world. One of the characters mentions a satyr. Or someone "falls to the earth." Or a siegemaster is bringing trebuchets to bear on a castle.

Do you see where I'm headed?

A satyr is a Greek word for a creature of decidedly Greek nature. How can someone "fall to the earth" if the make-believe world isn't called earth. Trebuchets and salet helmets, both French, don't bother me as much, but I ran out of examples, even though I know there are ten thousand examples that I can't remember right now because my muse is angry at me for saying I would make her my slave. ((breathe)).

The point is, does it bother you when an author uses a word that is alien to the world that they have created? I know, it's a little picky. Like I said, I ride the OCD Express when I write. But still. At least use the word Faun instead of Satyr. I think faun is more European.


"Je voudrais un casque du salet, s'il vous plait"

I know fantasy stories involve an understood translation of some sort, but shouldn't the translation be consistent? Am I the only one who is bothered by this? And what's the deal with dentistry? Isn't it time for a revolutionary development in dental technology? Something to replace the old drill-a-hole-in-your-teeth regime? Christ's sake, what's it been, like two hundred years? It's like a race for last place against the internal combustion engine.